"Will the coming millennium – 2000 AD – be focused on St. Joseph,
just as the first millennium centered on Christ, and as the second millennium
brought out the role of Mary in God’s plan for mankind?," the Reverend
Stanley Smolenski pondered. "There seems to be much pointing in that
direction."
The Catholic vicar at St. Martha’s Parish in Endfield, Connecticut
published his theological arguments on behalf of Joseph, the fatherly guardian
of Jesus, in a recent issue of the "Homiletic and Pastoral Review." It
was reprinted in the "Catholic Familyland" newspaper whose advisory
board includes dozens of Catholic bishops, archbishops, and cardinals.
"We already have a profound appreciation of Jesus and Mary," Rev.
Smolenski writes. "What is necessary is a similar appreciation of the third
member of the terrestrial trinity: St. Joseph."
Smolenski’s argument for a revival of Josephology in the Catholic Church
can be summarized like this:
However, such a claim receives strong reaction by church leaders in the
evangelical side of the church. "The shifting of the focus to Joseph is
another attempt by the agent of Satan to divert people away from their sincere
and pure devotion to Jesus Christ" (2 Cor. 11:3), wrote Mike Gendron, a
former Roman Catholic who now evangelizes Catholics through his
"Proclaiming the Gospel" ministry.
"Considering Joseph, the husband of Mary is mentioned only a handful of
times in the Bible, it appears to be another attempt to add to God’s word with
the teachings and traditions of men," Gendron argues. "In doing so
they will be adding yet another mediator between God and men and making the
simple way of salvation even more complex."
But Rev. Smolenski reasons that the ecumenical councils during the first
millennium clarified theological arguments for the humanity and divinity of
Christ. And with the second millennium brought Mary into focus with such dogmas
as the Immaculate Conception and the Assumption, as well as the beginning of the
age of Marian apparitions. So he concludes that the next millennium needs to
focus on Joseph to complete the newly discovered trinity, which makes perfect
sense to him in light of our "fatherless society."
The argument from scripture centers around the life of the son of Jacob, the
Joseph of the Old Testament whom God used to save the Israelites from famine in
Egypt. "As the patriarch Joseph achieved the title "savior of the
world" in Hebrew history" (Gen. 41:45), Smolenski notes, "should
there be any doubt that Joseph of Nazareth has a similar saving mission in our
times as he did in the life of the Holy Family?"
Does this mean that Joseph is now the proposed savior of the 21st Century? So
it would seem.
For the New Testament proof text he cites the words of Paul in 1 Cor. 4:15:
"You might have thousands of guardians in Christ, but not more than one
father; and it was I who begot you in Christ Jesus by preaching the
gospel." Wrote Smolenski, quoting his Catholic Bible. "If that Apostle
can make such a claim," He reasoned, "how much more should we see the
paternity, by grace, of St. Joseph over the entire mystical body of Christ. So
Joseph is, in a relative way, the spiritual Father of the mystical body, the
Church."
But former Dominican priest, Richard Bennett, publisher of the "Berean
Beacon" newsletter objects to the new Josephology. "If this was just
grown men playacting with God’s Word as theological toys it would be serious
enough," he responds. "It is however a breaking of God’s commandment
not to call up the dead (Deut. 18:10-11). The Roman Catholic Church [officially]
teaches their people to communicate with their "Terrestrial Trinity"
just as Stanley Smolenski and the Roman Catholic bishops, archbishops and
cardinals of ‘Catholic Familyland’ do."
To demonstrate this Bennett points to a traditional Catholic prayer to ‘Jesus,
Mary and Joseph’ that is widely used by the Catholic faithful.
"The Bible however teaches," warns Bennett, "’For there is
one God, and one mediator between God and man, the Man Christ Jesus’ (1 Tim.
2:5). And one name given to us for salvation. ‘Neither is there salvation in
any other, for there is none other name (Jesus Christ) under heaven given among
men whereby we must be saved’ (Acts 4:12)."
Rev. Smolenski’s proposed doctrine (going to Jesus through Mary and going
to Mary through Joseph) is not as new as it would seem. He is only trying to
attract more attention to a Catholic tradition that has been accepted in the
Roman Catholic Church for centuries. One thing for sure, if his proposed chain
of command gains momentum in the next millennium, access to the Lord Jesus
Christ for the Roman Catholic faithful promises to get more convoluted.